I. Bills and Resolutions II. House letter to President Bush III. APN on S. Res. 548 IV. Hagel on the Record V. APN Message to President Bush
APN Legislative Round-Up for the week ending August 4, 2006
I. Bills and Resolutions
II. House letter to President Bush
III. APN on S. Res. 548
IV. Hagel on the Record
V. APN Message to President Bush
============================
I. BILLS AND RESOLUTIONS
==============================
(Israel-Hezbollah) S. Res. 548: Introduced 8/3/06 by Senators Dodd (D-CT), Levin (D-MI) and Sununu (R-NH),
"Expressing the sense of the Senate regarding the need for the United States and the international community to
take certain actions with respect to hostilities between Hezbollah and Israel." Passed by Unanimous Consent
8/3/06.
(Magen David Adom) S. Con. Res. 113: Introduced 7/21/06 by Sen. Clinton (D-NY) and 13 cosponsors, "Congratulating
the Magen David Adom Society in Israel for achieving full membership in the International Red Cross and Red
Crescent Movement." Passed 8/1/06 by Unanimous Consent.
(Israel-Lebanon) S. Amdt. 4875 to H.R.5631: An amendment to the Defense Department Appropriations Act, offered
8/3/06 by Sen. Stabenow (D-MI) and 6 cosponsors, "To increase by $200,000,000 the amount appropriated or otherwise
made available by title IX for the purpose of supplying needed humanitarian assistance to the innocent Lebanese and
Israeli civilians who have been affected by the hostilities between Hezbollah and the Government of Israel." The
amendment was ruled out of order.
==============================
I. HOUSE LETTER TO PRESIDENT BUSH ==============================
On 7/28/06 Reps. Price (D-NC), Capps (D-CA), Filner (D-CA), and Leach (R-IA) sent a letter to President Bush urging
him to "join our allies in seeking an immediate ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah, with the understanding that
such a ceasefire must be followed by intensive diplomacy to establish an international military force in southern
Lebanon, dismantle Hezbollah's military capabilities, facilitate the return of kidnapped Israeli soldiers, and
support ongoing development of an autonomous, democratic government in Lebanon."
The letter can be read in its entirety at: http://www.house.gov/apps/list/speech/ca23_
capps/morenews/pr060731_ceasefire.html
============================
III. APN on S. RES. 548
============================
On August 3rd APN distributed the following statement on S. Res. 544:
APN Applauds Senate Passage of Resolution Supporting Ending Hostilities in the Israel-Hezbollah Conflict
Washington, D.C.-Americans for Peace Now (APN) today applauded the Senate's passage, by unanimous consent, of S.
Res. 548. APN is a Jewish, Zionist organization whose mission is to enhance Israel's security through peace and to
support the Israeli Peace Now movement.
"Members of the U.S. Senate, and especially Senators Dodd, Levin, and Sununu, deserve credit for passing this
measure," said Debra DeLee, President and CEO of Americans for Peace Now. "S. Res. 548 represents a constructive
message, reaffirming Israel's right to self-defense while recognizing the terrible damage that is occurring - in
terms of loss of life, terrorizing and displacement of civilians, and destruction of infrastructure."
"We are pleased," DeLee added, "that S. Res. 548 includes a clear call for the Bush Administration and the
international community to work urgently with the Governments of Israel and Lebanon to end the hostilities, ensure
the safe return of captured Israeli soldiers, and achieve a change in the security situation, including the
replacement of Hezbollah with Lebanese Government forces, and the deployment of an international stabilization
force in the area. APN also supports the call for an international donors conference to help rebuild infrastructure
destroyed during the hostilities."
"Finally, we applaud the Senate for including a call for the Bush Administration to remain engaged to promote
sustainable peace and security for Israel, Lebanon, and the greater Middle East. For too long this Administration
has failed to invest sufficient diplomatic energy to address conflicts in this volatile and strategically important
region, with very negative consequences for the people of the region and for U.S. vital interests."
Earlier today APN called on the President to work urgently to achieve a ceasefire and, once a ceasefire is in
place, to convene an international conference to launch Israeli- Arab peace negotiations, to include Lebanon, the
Palestinians, Syria, and any other regional parties that can be brought to the table.
============================
IV. HAGEL ON THE RECORD
===========================
On July 31st Sen. Chuck Hagel (R-NB) delivered the following statement on the Senate floor:
"Mr. President, the Middle East today is a region in crisis. After 3 weeks of escalating and continuing violence,
the potential for wider regional conflict becomes more real each day. The hatred in the Middle East is being driven
deeper and deeper into the fabric of the region, which will make any lasting and sustained peace effort very
difficult to achieve.
"How do we realistically believe that a continuation of the systematic destruction of an American friend, the
country and people of Lebanon, is going to enhance America's image and give us the trust and credibility to lead a
lasting and sustained peace effort in the Middle East?
"The sickening slaughter on both sides must end, and it must end now. President Bush must call for an immediate
cease-fire. This madness must stop. The Middle East today is more combustible and complex than it has ever been.
Uncertain popular support for regime legitimacy continues to weaken governments in the Middle East. Economic
stagnation, persistent unemployment, deepening despair, and wider unrest enhance the ability of terrorists to
recruit and succeed.
"An Iran with nuclear weapons raises the specter of broader proliferation and a fundamental strategic realignment
in the region, creating more regional instability. America's approach to the Middle East must be consistent and
sustained, and it must understand the history, the interests, and the perspectives of our regional friends and
allies.
"The United States will remain committed to defending Israel. Our relationship with Israel is a special and
historic one. But it need not and cannot be at the expense of our Arab and Muslim relationships. That is an
irresponsible and dangerous false choice.
"Achieving a lasting resolution to the Arab- Israeli conflict is as much in Israel's interest as any other country
in the world. Unending war will continually drain Israel of its human capital, resources, and energy as it
continually fights for its survival.
"The United States and Israel must understand that it is not in their long-term interests to allow themselves to
become isolated in the Middle East and the world. Neither can allow themselves to drift into an ``us against the
world'' global optic or zero-sum game. That would marginalize America's global leadership, our trust and influence,
further isolating Israel, and it would prove disastrous for both countries, as well as the region. It is in
Israel's interest, as much as ours, that the United States be seen by all states in the Middle East as fair. This
is the currency of trust.
"The world has rightly condemned the despicable actions of Hezbollah and Hamas terrorists who attacked Israel and
kidnapped Israeli soldiers. Israel has the undeniable right to defend itself against aggression. This is the right
of all nations.
"Hezbollah is a threat to Israel, to Lebanon, and to all who strive for lasting peace in the Middle East. However,
military action alone will not destroy Hezbollah or Hamas. Extended military action is tearing Lebanon apart,
killing innocent civilians, devastating its economy and infrastructure, and creating a humanitarian disaster,
further weakening Lebanon's fragile democratic government, strengthening popular Muslim and Arab support for
Hezbollah, and deepening hatred of Israel's position across the Middle East. The pursuit of tactical military
victories at the expense of the core strategic objective of Arab-Israeli peace is a hollow victory. The war against
Hezbollah and Hamas will not be won on the battlefield.
"To achieve a strategic shift in the conditions for Middle East peace, the United States must use the global
condemnation of terrorist acts as the basis for substantive change. For a lasting and popularly supported
resolution, only a strong Lebanese Government and a strong Lebanese Army, backed by the international community,
can rid Lebanon of these corrosive militias and terrorist organizations.
"President Bush and Secretary Rice must become and remain deeply engaged in the Middle East. Only U.S. leadership
can build a consensus of purpose among our regional and international partners. To lead and sustain U.S.
engagement, the President should appoint a statesman of global stature, experience, and ability to serve as his
personal envoy to the region. This individual would report directly to the President and be empowered with the
authority to speak and act for the President. Former Secretaries of State Baker and Powell fit this profile.
"The President must publicly decry the slaughter today and work toward an immediate cease-fire in the Middle East.
The U.N. Security Council must urgently adopt a new binding resolution that provides a comprehensive political,
security, and economic framework for Lebanon, Israel, and the region--a framework that begins with the immediate
cessation of violence.
"I strongly support the deployment of a robust international force along the Israel- Lebanon border to facilitate a
steady deployment of a strengthened Lebanese Army into southern Lebanon to eventually assume responsibility for
security and the rule of law.
"America must listen carefully to its friends, its partners in the region. Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, and
others--countries that understand the Middle East far better than we do--must commit to help resolve today's
crisis, and they must be active partners in helping realize the already- agreed-upon two-state solution.
"The core of all challenges in the Middle East remains the underlying Arab-Israeli conflict. The failure to address
this root cause will allow Hezbollah, Hamas, and other terrorists to continue to sustain popular Muslim and Arab
support--a dynamic that continues to undermine America's standing in the region and the Governments of Egypt,
Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and others, whose support is critical for any Middle East resolution.
"The United States should engage our Middle East and international partners to revive the Beirut Declaration, or
some version of that declaration, proposed by King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia and adopted unanimously by the Arab
League in March of 2002. In this historic initiative, the Arab world recognized Israel's right to exist and sought
to establish a path toward a two- state solution and broader Arab-Israeli peace. Even though Israel could not
accept it as it was written, it represented a very significant starting point--starting point-- document initiated
by Arab countries. Today, we need a new Beirut Declaration-type initiative. We squandered the last one.
"The concept and intent of the 2002 Beirut Declaration is as relevant today as it was in 2002. An Arab-initiated,
Beirut-type declaration would reinvest regional Arab States with a stake in achieving progress toward
Israeli-Palestinian peace. This type of initiative would offer a positive alternative--a positive
alternative--vision for Arab populations to the ideology and goals of Islamic extremists. The United States must
explore this approach as part of its diplomatic engagement in the Middle East.
"Lasting peace in the Middle East, and stability and security for Israel, will come only from a regionally oriented
political settlement. Former American Middle East Envoy Dennis Ross once observed that in the Middle East a process
is necessary because a process absorbs events. Without a process, events become crises. He was right. Look at where
we are today in the Middle East with no process. Crisis diplomacy is no substitute for sustained, day-to-day
engagement.
"America's approach to Syria and Iran is inextricably tied to Middle East peace. Whether or not they were directly
involved in the latest Hezbollah and Hamas aggression in Israel, both countries exert influence in the region in
ways that undermine stability and security. As we work with our friends and allies to deny Syria and Iran any
opportunity to further corrode the situation in Lebanon and the Palestinian territories, both Damascus and Tehran
must hear from America directly.
"As John McLaughlin, the former Deputy Director of the Central Intelligence Agency, recently wrote in the
Washington Post--and I quote Mr. McLaughlin- 'Even superpowers have to talk to bad guys. The absence of a
diplomatic relationship with Iran and the deterioration of the one with Syria--two countries that bear enormous
responsibility for the current crisis [in the Middle East]- -leave the United States with fewer options and levers
than might otherwise have been the case. Distasteful as it might have been to have or to maintain open and normal
relations with such states, the absence of such relations ensures that we will have more blind spots than we can
afford and that we will have to deal through surrogates on issues of vital importance to the United States.'
"Ultimately, the United States will need to engage Iran and Syria with an agenda open to all areas of agreement and
disagreement. For this dialog to have any meaning or possible lasting relevance, it should encompass the full
agenda of issues.
"There is very little good news coming out of Iraq today. Increasingly vicious sectarian violence continues to
propel Iraq toward civil war.
"The U.S. announcement last week to send additional U.S. troops and military police back into Baghdad reverses last
month's decision to have Iraqi forces take the lead in Baghdad and represents a dramatic setback for the U.S. and
the Iraqi Government.
"The Iraqi Government has limited ability to enforce the rule of law in Iraq, especially in Baghdad. Green zone
politics appear to have little bearing or relation to the realities of the rest of Iraq. The Iraqis will continue
to face difficult choices over the future of their country.
"The day-to-day responsibilities of governing and security will soon have to be assumed by Iraqis. This is not
about setting a timeline. This is about understanding the implications of the forces of reality. This reality is
being determined by Iraqis, not Americans.
"America is bogged down in Iraq and this is limiting our diplomatic and military options. The longer America
remains in Iraq in its current capacity, the deeper the damage to our force structure--particularly the U.S.
Army.
"And it will continue to place more limitations on an already dangerously overextended force structure that will
further limit our options and public support.
"The Middle East crisis represents a moment of great danger, but it is also an opportunity.
"Crisis focuses the minds of leaders and the attention of nations. The Middle East need not be a region forever
captive to the fire of war and historical hatred. It can avoid this fate if the United States pursues sustained and
engaged leadership worthy of our history, purpose, and power. America cannot fix every problem in the world; nor
should it try. But we must get the big issues and important relationships right and concentrate on those.
"We know that without engaged and active American leadership, the world is more dangerous. The United States must
focus all of its leadership and resources on ending this madness in the Middle East now.
===================================
V. APN MESSAGE TO PRESIDENT BUSH ===================================
On August 3rd APN issued this following statement calling on President Bush to broker a ceasefire and convene an
international peace summit:
Americans for Peace Now (APN) today again criticized the Bush Administration for failing to invest sufficient
efforts to resolve the military crisis devastating Israel and Lebanon. APN called on President Bush to work
urgently to broker a ceasefire and to convene an international Middle East peace conference. APN is a Jewish,
Zionist organization whose mission is to enhance Israel's security through peace and to support the Israeli Peace
Now movement.
"It is time for the U.S. to show real leadership in the Middle East. We call on President Bush to work urgently to
broker a ceasefire and accompanying arrangements to achieve the release of abducted Israeli soldiers and stabilize
the situation on the ground," said Debra DeLee, President of Americans for Peace Now.
"At the same time, we call on the President to match the leadership demonstrated by his father, who in 1991
convened Israeli-Arab peace talks in Madrid, ushering in the first decade in Israel's history without an
Israeli-Arab war. President Bush should mobilize regional parties and the international community around a peace
conference, to be convened as soon as a ceasefire is in place, to launch Israeli- Arab negotiations that include
not only Lebanon, but also the Palestinians, Syria, and any other parties in the region that can be brought to the
table."
Criticizing the Administration's performance, DeLee noted, "Violence continues to escalate in the Middle East,
including the tragic events in Qana, but the Administration continues to demonstrate insufficient seriousness about
resolving the crisis. To save lives and prevent further suffering, to save Lebanon's democratic government, to stop
the growing influence of Iran, and to avert a long-term, open-ended Israeli military campaign in Lebanon, it is
vital to end the violence as quickly as possible. Consensus is building in support of both a ceasefire and, as part
of that ceasefire, the deployment of an international force in southern Lebanon to help stabilize the situation on
the ground, facilitate Lebanon extending its sovereignty over all of its territory, and ensure that Hezbollah does
not exploit a ceasefire to re-arm and re-organize for further attacks. Deployment of such a force will require
Hezbollah to remove its militias from the area."
DeLee emphasized that the U.S. must think beyond a ceasefire and an international stabilization force. "In the
long-term, real security on Israel's northern border, just like security along Israel's borders with Egypt and
Jordan, can only come through negotiations that produce peace agreements and accompanying security guarantees.
Similarly, in the long-term, real security in the West Bank and Gaza will only come through negotiations with the
Palestinians."
DeLee added that the success of any regional peace talks will be linked to progress on the Israeli-Palestinian
track. "We urge the U.S. to adopt a new approach regarding the Palestinians," she said. "The U.S. must look for
ways to strengthen Palestinian moderates and to engage more moderate elements of the Hamas leadership. Renewing
negotiations will empower Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and other moderates and force Hamas leaders to choose
between an extremist, rejectionist agenda and a nationalist agenda that is supported by the Palestinian
people."
For more information, contact APN Government Relations Director Lara Friedman at 202/728-1893, or at
lfriedman@peacenow.org.